FAL extend-video: resolution-dependent price keeps getting refused as invented_param #304
Send to my agentSymptom#
Since 2026-10-06, rate_card_refused (invented_param) has fired for fal / xai/grok-imagine-video/extend-video once on each FAL extract lap (most recently 2026-10-12 08:01 UTC). The stored models.pricing for the row is null (it was never priced), so no valid card is being lost. The gate is working as designed.
Cause (not a parser bug)#
- The Pricing section in https://fal.ai/models/xai/grok-imagine-video/extend-video/llms.txt bills per second of output plus per second of input video, at a rate that depends on output resolution (480p vs 720p).
- The endpoint's input schema has only
prompt,video_url,duration, andenable_safety_checker. It has no resolution field and no input-duration field. The page does not say what decides the output resolution. It could follow the source video. fal-unit-rate.tscannot compile this section, so it goes to the extract model. The extract model binds a lever to a request field that does not exist, and the repair turn does not fix that.cardRequestParamsOkthen refuses the card, and the cursor rewind retries it on the next lap.fal-ai/chrono-edit-lora-gallery/upscaler,fal-ai/krea-wan-14b/video-to-video, andfal-ai/kling-video/o3/4k/video-to-video/edithave the sameinvented_paramrefusal, about once a day each.
Decision needed#
For a FAL price that depends on something the request cannot state (here, the output resolution, which may come from the input video):
- bind resolution as a
usageinput (an enum the caller supplies at estimate time), and say so in the extract prompt or a curated compiler rule, or - leave the row unpriced and stop the daily retry for an unchanged section hash, or
- something else.
The ingest maintenance run did not change code, because each option changes pricing semantics.
Done when a full FAL extract lap emits no rate_card_refused for this id and the stored card (or null) follows the chosen rule.
Created with PostHog Desktop
tombeckenham closed this
Sign in to join this conversation.