Oracle: revalidate retained applied-receipt and lazy child-ready receiving gaps #2342
Send to my agentRetained obligations#
The release deferral record retains two receiving gaps after the P06/P07/P13/P14 prose corrections:
- Release P08: exercise the actual custom-adapter fenced callback while it holds an establishing applied receipt before load settlement.
- Release P14: compare the actual lazy child-ready call outcome with the existing source-health model, rather than catching and discarding a throw.
These are historical coverage obligations, not newly reproduced production defects. Revalidate each against current main before implementing anything; later work may already discharge one. The release P08 identifier here is not the separate metadata P8 / #2317 investigation.
Per-cut acceptance#
- Identify the current primary executable owner through the coverage map and read its contract and limits.
- Preserve the accepted owner, fresh-run neighbors and omitted-callback reach controls from the retained campaign.
- Add the actual receiving observation to that owner's model/driver/comparison, with legal generated histories and measured reach.
- Demonstrate sensitivity by omitting or corrupting the actual callback/outcome and showing that the intended comparison rejects it. Catching an error without judging its outcome supplies no receiving evidence.
- Preserve current laws and budgets. If a production failure is discovered, show parent RED before repair, repaired GREEN and a hostile mutant, and state the bounded class covered.
Record each cut's disposition independently. A source/prose correction alone does not discharge an executable receiving obligation.
Related: #2118 covers broader shared adapter settlement/readiness conformance. This issue keeps these two concrete retained release cuts visible without treating that larger proposal as completed evidence.
Sign in to join this conversation.
Fresh revalidation on freshly fetched
origin/mainbaabf57a0f110d57ad9bb7b81148466b18fbe0d1: both retained cuts remain open.Release P08 — actual documented/custom guidance callback: the current
packages/db/skills/db-core/custom-adapter/SKILL.mdon-demand fence callscommit()without awaiting its receipt. A fresh probe extracts and executes that exact fenced callback through a real Collection, invoked outside the independent mutation holding application. At the cut: one actual commit, receipt pending, row invisible, but load already fulfilled. The applied-settlement comparison fails (fulfilledversus requiredpending). The same extracted callback with only an awaited receipt passes; an omitted-callback observation is rejected before granting reach. This is a demonstrated guidance callback violation ofLoadSubsetFn/architecture law 7, not a claim about a shipped Query or persistence adapter. No guidance or production repair was made. The fixed diagnostic does not supply the missing committed generated receiver. This is unrelated to metadata P8/#2317.Release P14 — lazy child-ready outcome: the unchanged lazy owner passes 71 tests, but still catches/discards the actual call's exception. Four additional scratch histories reuse its shared model/driver and preserve failed-first-load, fresh-run, reload and absent-callback neighbors. An in-memory overlay throws only after actual present callbacks execute; the existing comparison still passes all 75 tests, including two actual failed-first-load callback throws. All 21 existing lazy reach states remain reached. This is a surviving wrong-outcome mutant demonstrating the observation gap, not a baseline production RED. Absent optional callbacks receive no actual-call reach credit; generated fail→actual-ready coverage still needs to be added.
The existing receipt-refinement and documented-mutation neighbor controls also pass (15 tests). Keep both cuts open until the actual receiving observations are integrated into their owners, with generated per-cut reach and sensitivity that rejects the wrong callback/outcome. Production and tracked tests stayed unchanged; no broad adapter or #2118 conformance closure is claimed.