Describe the bug#
When a form is created with defaultValues that include a field whose value arrives asynchronously, that field does not receive its updated default value after the async data loads if the user has already edited another field in the meantime.
The async field stays empty instead of being populated with the loaded default.
This is important to make forms usable while small parts of it are still loading, avoiding the need to block the entire form to workaround the issue. In our case, the user should be able to modify other fields, even if the form is not ready for submission yet (we disable the submit button and the pending fields).
Your minimal, reproducible example#
https://codesandbox.io/p/sandbox/goofy-chatelet-q8r3ff
Steps to reproduce#
In the reproduction example:
- Render the form (the async field starts with an empty default).
- Before the async value resolves (3s), type into the
name field.
- Wait for the async value to load.
- Observe that
asyncField remains empty instead of showing "loaded default".
Expected behavior#
When async data arrives and defaultValues are updated on re-render, untouched fields should receive their new default values even if other fields have already been edited.
Screenshots or Videos#
https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/f2892c24-d4a9-4a6e-9fee-b8800d3d44db
Platform#
TanStack Form adapter: React (@tanstack/react-form)
Browser: Chrome (latest)
OS: macOS
TanStack Form adapter#
None
TanStack Form version#
1.33.0
TypeScript version#
No response
Additional context#
No response
Tried resetting the field inside a
useEffect(a not good workaround in my opinion), while it worked for text fields, it did not work array fields, which is our current use case:https://codesandbox.io/p/devbox/modest-paper-sv8dqp